Huge Protests in Germany Against Government’s Lockdowns


The German Press is starting to wake up at last after a period of just saying Yes mam! They have run the story that if we acted rationally, we could quickly overcome the consequences of the corona crisis. But politics is deliberately spreading panic among the population and stirring up fear – and in this way causes a severe economic crisis.

For today, the initiative “lateral thinking 711” announced a rally with 500,000 participants in Stuttgart have registered. But there are protests rising in Munich and Berlin. The number of people may reach 1 million.

The government is trying with the aid of most press to label these people as right-wing racists because they cannot address their actions on false forecasts. Meanwhile, unknown persons have set up a replica tombstone in front of Chancellor Angela Merkel’s (CDU) constituency office in Stralsund symbolizing her reign some call of Terror between the refugees and now the virus over-reaction has destroy their lib=vlihoods and their future.

On top of that, the rising resentment against the Eurozone control from Brussels has many wanting to kill the Euro and return to national currencies. I have warned that the cultural divides are far too great and this virus is being used for a total environmental reconstruction of the economy by sheer force. The lack of a transition or any planning whatsoever has cast the livelihoods and future of the world population is tremendous jeopardy and has drastically increased the outcome of our forecasts for not just the collapse of the Euro, but the rise in civil unrest and international war.

Trump has been advised that there is a tremendous risk rising of war. According to sources, the U.S. government is reportedly working to replace all industrial supply chains from China. This is a strategic move in light of rising tensions. But this has already been implemented by the global ban on travel and movement of commerce thanks to the Coronavirus scare worldwide. What Trump will be looking at is replacing those supply chains as they are closed at this moment.

This lockdown over the virus has destroyed the supply chains in so many areas because Gates and crew thought they could just destroy fossil fuels and rebuild without any consideration of how people make transitions for employment. During the Great Depression, it was the Dust Bowl that destroyed agricultural jobs and created the Hobo Movement because people had no income. This time it is Gates and he never considered what he was doing to society – only his Climate Change dream.

Even in the United States, we are witnessing rising civil unrest against UNCONSTITUTIONALlockdowns. This is going to rise as we head into November and the Democratic states, like California, think if they oppress the people hard enough, they will blame Trump.

Pelosi Passes $3 Trillion Bill Dividing Even Democrats Just for Politics


Nancy Pelosi, who represents California rather than the nation, is about as unfit to be a leader of any party in Congress. She has pushed through her House Democrat Bill calling for $3 trillion in coronavirus spending bill Friday night, despite pushback from liberals and moderates within their ranks as well from Republicans. She knows this is very bad for the country and is trying to allow anyone, including illegal aliens to vote, to defeat Trump. She knows this will not pass and Trump will not sign it.

Pelosi’s $3 trillion spending proposal is Washington at its worst. Pelosi sees only an opportunity to exploit this crisis to pass their partisan agenda.

While millions of Americans are out of work and Trump is trying to get them back on the job by safely reopening our country which is the ONLY way to approach this because no amount of relief will allow people to live without income indefinitely. Banks cannot suspect payments forever and prolonging the reopening puts at Irish the complete collapse of real estate for perhaps the next 12 years. As foreclosures increase, prices fall and banks have already just about doubled requirements to even get a mortgage. With 30% to 50% of the population without a job, it will be impossible to support the real estate market.

Pelosi has stuffed in her bill outrageous things that have nothing to do with helping the people now!

  •  Mass voting by mail is her real dream where as part of this “Coronavirus relief” she wants to dictate how states run their elections so anyone can vote without having to prove who they are – illegal aliens and tourists – her covert attempt to legalize voter fraud to win in November (Every American Should Be Outraged at this scheme).
  • A BAN on information about low-cost health insurance. The House Democrats want to forbid the government from sharing any information about lower-cost health options such as association plans or short-term plans. Even as families try to cope with job and wage losses, Pelosi doesn’t want them to learn about options that are up to 60% cheaper than Obamacare.
  •  Stimulus checks for illegal aliens who already do not pay taxes to eliminate Social Security numbers, yet she opposes helping self-employed and parttime workers not entitled to unemployment.
  •  Bailouts the Democratic States that refuse to lift lockdowns that are UNCONSTITUTIONAL,Pelosi wants to hand states more than $1 trillion in cash for state and local governments, mostly in the form of unrestricted aid that doesn’t need to be used to offset Coronavirus costs. This is a covert attempt to bailout Democratic states that never funded their Pensions and were collapsing before the virus, raising questions if the Democrats have exploited the virus as the excuse they cannot pay pensions.

Nevertheless, she is deliberately pushing the economy over the edge for political gain. The vote passed on a 208-199 vote, with 14 Democrats voting against it. This is what I have been warning about. The Democratic Party may split out these types of actions because she cares nothing about what is good for the country or the people. Moderate Democrats are starting to break ranks with her leadership. Her claims that she prays for Trump at night are far from genuine. If she even prays at all, it is that her insider trading is not discovered and that he drops dead while tweeting.

Already, there are others besides Elon Musk looking to moving companies out of California. Even high-Tech companies cannot survive working from home. You lose synergy that emerges in a creative environment. These brain-dead California politicians are just out of their minds. They are destroying the economy of California and there will be no putting it back again.

Democratic states are deliberately refusing to open up. LA County in California issued a new “Stay At Home” order and admits there will be no TERMINATE of that order – it is endless. They have refused to allow any retail business to open that is inside a shopping mall. J.C. Penny just filed for bankruptcy on Friday. Just to win an election they are deliberately destroying the economy because they are covertly trying to rebuild it from scratch with Gates’ Zero CO2. The world will just NEVER be the same when they get done with this. They have openly stated, “It is still safer to remain at home, COVID-19 has not changed.”  They have also explained that some of the county’s dates for phases of reopening might not coincide with those in California. Any State that imposes their own stay-at-home orders should NOT be bailed out – it was their decision.

I have warned that my greatest fear was NOT Trump – but what comes AFTER Trump. Politics has completely broken down to the point NOBODY will again accept a democratic outcome. This, unfortunately, is our political fate as we head into 2032. We will run our models on the entire election outcome 2020. This is a huge task. Not just if Trump wins or not. We have to look at the whole enchilada because the level of corruption, altered votes, and outright fraud will be at a historical high for this election. I have NEVER seen the model project such an increase in outright fraud as we are showing for November 2020.

Is Trump Mobilizing Military for Vaccines?


Trump has come out and said he will mobilize the military to administer vaccines by the end of the year when they are ready. Many see this as a betrayal of everything he has been fighting against. I have advised many, many governments in times of crisis. What Trump has done is actually necessary. The media has so mentally terrorized the population that you do see people driving in their cars alone still wearing a mask. As one reader put it, they probably also sleep alone at night with both a mask and a condom just to be safe. These people are hopeless. You will never convince them it is safe to go outside without a mask. Even the CDC has come out at stated: “There’s no good reason to use these masks except psychologically you think you’re doing something.” If Trump said get some sunlight it is good for you, they would only go out at night.

The flu season 2018-2019 saw, according to the CDC, an estimated 35.5 million people getting sick with influenza, 16.5 million people going to a health care provider for their illness, 490,600 hospitalizations, and 34,200 deaths from influenza. The overall numbers for influenza during the 2017-2018 season was an estimated 45 million influenza illnesses, 21 million influenza-associated medical visits, 810,000 influenza-related hospitalizations, and 61,000 influenza-associated deaths. The extent of the fraud by attributing flu deaths to COVID-19 warrants a criminal investigation for fraud. They get paid more for COVID-19 death but they are not testing to prove the cause of death. If I was a doctor, you better correct those death certificates because you can go to jail for a very long-time. It’s the same as Medicare fraud.

Against this backdrop, the SWAMP has won a decisive victory. Trump is fighting to keep the economy open but this is not easy. The BEST advice I would give is to play with the vaccine of your enemy. Yes, proclaim the military will be mobilized to provide the vaccine and they cannot use that as a campaign issue. There is NO CONSTITUTIONAL authority to make them MANDATORY. I would play their game, disarm them with the vaccine issue, and then make it available on a VOLUNTARYbasis for all the brainwashed people.

I have advised governments in times of crisis BECAUSE I understand the game. This is like playing chess. You must develop a strategy, disarm your opponent taking their key pieces, and then move in for the checkmate. You cannot approach these things superficially. That is why I have been called in so many times. They know I get it and it must be politically strategic. I have even been asked if I would teach at two of the top 10 universities in the world. I declined because I just do not have the time. I will put it in a book perhaps and let it go from there. I know a lot of people think they can advise governments with an idea. Sorry, you have to have a track record. Nobody will risk their career on a hypothetical proposition. It does not work that way!

I would hire a TOTALLY unconnected lab to analyze any such vaccine to see what it really contains. The Democrats better pray there is no hidden agenda for those who will be rushing out will be the very Democrats they have been scaring the hell out of just for fun sake.

I have made it clear, they ONLY way to fight this psychological war the media and the left have been waging is to criminally investigate the insider trading right up to Gates. The strategic option is to PROVE this has been a fraud to make money. You cannot fight on statistics because they control too many bogus study groups. We need to change the defense and NOW for the November election or we will lose everything we once assumed was normal. Their designs on creating a Zero CO2 would are insane. You cannot recreate the economy that no government created. It is the Invisible Hand – not governments. Marx tried that and it collapsed.

Indeed, a quiet person may be very profound and rarely says much. However, still waters run deep as Anthony Trollope once said. In this case, Trump seriously underestimated how deep this Swamp really is. He has failed in this regard. Neither can the swamp be drained nor term limits put in place without revolution where you get to start all over again.

Is Free Will a Sin?


 

Re-Tweet Posts – No Problem


COMMENT: Dear Mr Armstrong,

I notice only some of your Armstrong Economics blog postings are being put in your @StrongEconomics Twitter account. I had retweeted your Twitter 5th May “Why is nobody Investigating Bill Gates ?” and 8th May “Gates – The Forecast” to tweets under Judicial Watch (& #ReOpenAmerica) and received decent number of likes and retweets. It is good to know that there are many people who also see through this farce.

Perhaps a suggestion from you to us readers to retweet your postings will quickly spread the message. I only retweet those postings in your Twitter account but not from your website.

By the way. Judicial Watch on 4 May filed a FOIA lawsuit for NIH communication records with WHO.

God bless and looking forward to your Webinar in lieu of the WEC. Gosh, I shall miss meeting you this year.

Best regards,
vy

REPLY: The posts on this blog can be Tweeted, forwarded, and referenced. This is an open public blog. They outnumber us, for the left is always the most violent and active.

Full-Blown Wuhan Virus Propaganda Now From Press


COMMENT: Yes, MSM is hyping and misleading the public on the risks of re-opening the economy. Their news (rather panic-porn) implied that countries had to shut down nation-wide again after reopening the economy because of infections resurgence. That is not the case in South Korea and China.

In China, certainly there are some small clusters outbreak after reopening and it is dealt with on targeted basis location by location depending on severity. The rest of the country is fully open and the government message to the people is a positive tone – like “yes, there is some risks of scattered cases or clusters outbreaks, and if it happens, we shall deal with it and we don’t expect major outbreaks”.

This gives confidence to the people. You can see crowds in shopping complex, large groups dancing in open courtyards, eating in restaurants (less business than before but more due to income impact rather than fear) etc.

That’s what friends in China are telling me and sending me pictures.

VY

REPLY: This is clearly propaganda from the left media and all they care about is the agenda to defeat Trump AT ALL COSTS. They care nothing about the people, the country, or their future. They are toasting every job loss as another victory for themselves. This is going to turn very ugly after the election. Neither side will now accept the declared winner.

Acting DNI Ric Grenell Announces Organizational Changes to National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC)…


The Terror Threat Integration Center (TTIC) was created in 2003 by George W Bush and was first headed by John Brennan. In August 2004, and at the recommendation of the 9/11 Commission, TTIC was incorporated into the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) by Executive Order (EO) 13354. [LINK]

Friday evening Acting Director of National Intelligence Richard “Ric” Grenell announces some modifications to the NCTC to streamline activity and avoid redundancy.

On the surface the ODNI announcement appears to be a bureaucratic realignment of priorities:

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Acting Director of National Intelligence Richard Grenell today announced several organizational changes to the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), which is part of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI).

Based on the recommendations of career Intelligence Community (IC) officers, the reforms will increase efficiency by avoiding duplication of effort, strengthen support to and burden-sharing with NCTC’s IC partners on counterterrorism issues, and enhance NCTC’s integration within the broader ODNI organization.

NCTC Acting Director Lora Shiao said the changes will allow NCTC to focus its mission to better address evolving national security needs. (read more)

It has been suspected for several years the activities of the NCTC were part of the system alignment that allowed Obama-era intelligence actors to weaponize the NSA database.

Essentially behind the writing of the FISA court review (footnote 69), there appeared to be a clouding of intelligence distinctions between the CIA (foreign) and FBI (domestic), through the use of counterintelligence and the NCTC.

Knowing the scale of intelligence weaponization for political purposes that we are now aware of; and accepting a nefarious intention on behalf of federal actors looking for unique ways to skirt laws, rules and regulations on domestic surveillance; the morphing of the “sister” agencies to exploit intelligence gathering makes sense.

One approach of this nefarious intent would be “reverse targeting”, which is similar to the Flynn-Kislyak call issues.  Target a foreign person’s communication as an end-around to avoid the necessary warrant for the American on the other end of the contact.  In practice this would look like this:

The FBI (counterintelligence division) knows an American contacted a foreign person.  The FBI wants to know what the contact was about, but doesn’t have evidence to cut through the legal privacy protections.  So the FBI asks their ‘sister’ the CIA, to extract the foreign person’s information from the NSA intercepts (FBI gives specific date and time). The CIA then extracts the result and the NCTC is used as the hub where the resulting intelligence information is stored, then shared.

Obviously we have no idea whether today’s realignment of NCTC priorities has any bearing on the system structure used to carry out prior corrupt intelligence exploits; but it’s possible this issue is a part of the underlying change.

Jack Posobiec

✔@JackPosobiec

BREAKING: DNI @RichardGrenell is placing Election Security candidate briefings with the IC where it belongs and out of the realm of federal law enforcement

View image on Twitter

Richard Grenell

✔@RichardGrenell

Zachary Cohen

✔@ZcohenCNN

“President Trump did not nominate you for confirmation as permanent DNI, and it would be inappropriate for you to pursue any additional leadership, organizational, or staffing changes to ODNI during your temporary tenure,” @RepAdamSchiff wrote in a letter to Grenell on April 7. https://twitter.com/ODNIgov/status/1261401622355128320 …

UPDATE: Recently Released Comey Testimony Provides Further Evidence of The Original Flynn 302 Written by Pientka Before It Mysteriously Went Missing…


FBI Agents Peter Strzok and Joe Pientka interviewed National Security Advisor Michael Flynn on January 24, 2017. According to documents presented in the court case, agent Peter Strzok did the questioning and agent Joe Pientka took most of the notes.

Following the interview agent Pientka then took his hand-written notes and generated an official FD-302; an FBI report of the interview itself. There has been a great deal of debate over the first draft, the original FD-302 as it was written by Joe Pientka. In the case against Flynn the DOJ prosecutors never presented the original Pientka 302.

On May 2, 2020, the DOJ, using new information gathered by U.S. Attorney Jeff Jensen, declassified and released a segment of James Comey testimony that was previously hidden.  Within the transcript Comey says Pientka wrote the Flynn 302 on January 24thimmediately following the interview. [Screengrab below – pdf here ]

That January 24, 2017, version of the 302 is the one that has gone missing.

People defending the FBI have even said it never existed.  However, the testimony of FBI Director James Comey proves the 302 was drafted on January 24th.

Additionally, recent evidence from Brady material turned over to the defense by auditing attorney Jeff Jensen showed FBI lawyer Lisa Page and FBI Agent Peter Strzok rewriting, editing and shaping the 302 on February 10, 2017, more than two weeks later:

Lisa Page is “pissed off” because Peter Strzok previously edited the 302 and she says he “didn’t even attempt to make this cogent and readable.”

Peter Strzok replies back to Lisa Page that he was “trying to completely re-write the thing so as to save Joe’s voice”, because Joe Pientka was the actual author.

Peter Strzok is re-writing the interview notes of Pientka in order to construct the framework to accuse Flynn of lying. Lisa Page is editing the re-write to make it more cogent and readable.

The question has remained: Where is the original 302 report as written by Pientka?

While the question(s) around the missing original 302 have yet to be reconciled, one possible path to discover its location and a copy of its original content lies in the testimony of Sally Yates. Former DAG Sally Yates testified to congress that after the Flynn interview DOJ-National Security Division:

“The DOJ-National Security Division received a detailed readout from the FBI agents who had interviewed Flynn.” Yates said she felt “it was important to get this information to the White House as quickly as possible.”

Yates is describing getting briefed on the same information contained in the Pientka 302. An initial briefing on the evening of January 24th, or and a more detailed briefing the morning of the 25th.  DAG Yates was having meetings about the topic.

The calendar of DOJ-NSD Associate Deputy AG Tashina Gauhar shows meetings with Sally Yates which align with the discussions of the Flynn interview and Yates receiving a summary on the 24th and a detailed summary on the 25th:

Schedule of Associate Deputy Attorney General Tashina Gauhar

In the DOJ motion to dismiss the case against Flynn, the records indicate Yates received a summary of the interview the night of the 24th, and the full detailed record came on the morning of January 25th:

.

Aligning with what Sally Yates previously described, James Comey admits the FD-302 draft was written on January 24th; providing the material for the Yates briefings:

Together with DOJ-NSD head Mary McCord, Sally Yates used briefing from the 302 of m Joe Pientka to travel to the White House on January 26th and brief White House counsel Don McGahn about the Flynn interview contrast against the content of the previously captured call between Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak and Lt. Gen Mike Flynn.

If the FBI search for the original sentinel entry of the Pientka 302 is mysteriously impossible, perhaps the DOJ should go and get the readout provided to the DOJ-NSD on the evening of January 24th, and morning of January 25th, 2017.

Sally Yates and the original Pientka FD-302 report.

Yates testimony below:

•Wednesday January 25th, 2017, – The Department of Justice, National Security Division, (at this timeframe Mary McCord was head of the DOJ-NSD) – received a detailed readout from the FBI agents who had interviewed Flynn. Yates said she felt “it was important to get this information to the White House as quickly as possible.”

•Thursday January 26th – (morning) Sally Yates called White House Counsel Don McGahn first thing that morning to tell him she had “a very sensitive matter” that had to be discussed face to face. McGahn agreed to meet with Yates later that afternoon.

•Thursday January 26th – (afternoon) Sally Yates traveled to the White House along with a senior member of the DOJ’s National Security Division, “who was overseeing the matter”, that is Mary McCord. This was Yates’ first meeting with McGahn in his office, which also acts as a sensitive compartmented information facility (SCIF).

Yates said she began their meeting by laying out the media accounts and media statements made by Vice President Mike Pence and other high-ranking White House officials about General Flynn’s activity “that we knew not to be the truth.”

According to Sally Yates testimony, she and Mary McCord presented all the information to McGahn so the White House could take action that they deemed appropriate. When asked by McGahn if Flynn should be fired, Yates answered, “that really wasn’t our call.”

Yates also said her decision to notify the White House counsel had been discussed “at great length.” According to her testimony: “Certainly leading up to our notification on the 26th, it was a topic of a whole lot of discussion in DOJ and with other members of the intel community.”

•Friday January 27th – (morning) White House Counsel Don McGahn called Yates in the morning and asked if she could come back to his office.

•Friday January 27th – (late afternoon) According to her testimony, Sally Yates returned to the White House late that afternoon. One of McGahn’s topics discussed was whether Flynn could be prosecuted for his conduct.

Specifically, according to Yates, one of the questions *McGahn asked Yates: “Why does it matter to DOJ if one White House official lies to another?” She explained that it “was a whole lot more than that,” and reviewed the same issues outlined the prior day.

McGahn then expressed his concern that taking any action might interfere with the FBI investigation of Flynn, and Yates said it wouldn’t: “It wouldn’t really be fair of us to tell you this and then expect you to sit on your hands,” Yates claims to have told McGahn.

McGahn asked if he could look at the underlying evidence of Flynn’s conduct, and she said they would work with the FBI over the weekend and “get back with him on Monday morning.”

•Friday January 27th, 2017 – (evening) In what appears to be only a few hours later, President Trump is having dinner with FBI Director James Comey where President Trump asked if he was under investigation. Trump was, but to continue the auspices of the ongoing investigation, Comey lied and told him he wasn’t.

Sally Yates received a detailed briefing from the original 302 (January 25th) via James Comey; and then went to the White House and informed Don McGahn (January 26th) about the nature of the interview.

The Flynn 302 was edited by Page and Strzok on February 10th.  The 302 was changed and altered to match the FBI claims of a discrepancy.  Flynn was fired on Feb 13th.  The Flynn 302 was debated again on Feb 14th and entered into the record on February 15th.

Sally Yates was fired, and later testified to congress on May 8, 2017.

Bottom line the Flynn 302 was written on January 24, 2017.  James Comey and Andew McCabe saw it; and Sally Yates was briefed from it.

So where is it?

President Trump Impromptu Remarks Departing White House – Video and Transcript…


Chopper pressers are the best pressers.  President Trump delivers remarks to the press pool as he departs the White House for Camp David.  [Video and Transcript Below]

A curious group accompanies President Trump to Camp David this weekend along with chief of staff Mark Meadows.  POTUS is bringing House Leader Kevin McCarthy, GOP Reps. Dan Crenshaw, Matt Gaetz, Devin Nunes, Jim Jordan, Elise Stefanik and Lee Zeldin.

The House group represents a team well versed in the Obamagate and Spygate issues.  Along with the need to organize a political effort against Pelosi’s $3 trillion spending fiasco; perhaps the team is doing some big ugly political planning.

.

[Transcript] – THE PRESIDENT: So we’ll be going to Camp David. We have a lot of meetings scheduled. I think they’ll be very successful meetings. We’re getting a lot of gear out. We’re getting a lot of gowns out — protective equipment. And the governors have all been very thankful. We received a lot of calls today from governors. They’re very thankful for the job we’re doing. And that’s good.

Do you have any questions? Please.

Q Yeah, what’s the topic of the discussion at Camp David this weekend?

THE PRESIDENT: Go ahead.

Q What’s the topic of the discussion at Camp David this weekend?

THE PRESIDENT: So we have a lot of discussions going on at Camp David, some military and some other than military. We’ll probably report back on it on Monday.

Q Why are you not wanting to talk to President Xi right now, of China?

THE PRESIDENT: I just don’t want to talk to him right now. We’ll — we’ll see what happens over the next little while. They’re buying a lot of our material. They’re spending a lot on the trade deal, but the trade deal — I don’t know, somehow I lost a little flavor for it. You can understand.

Go ahead.

Q Sir, how many ventilators are you sending to India?

THE PRESIDENT: We’re sending a lot of ventilators to India. I spoke to Prime Minister Modi, and we’re sending quite a few ventilators to India. We have a tremendous supply of ventilators . So —

Q Mr. President? Mr. President, right here.

Q Sir, who do you think should go to jail, sir?

THE PRESIDENT: Go ahead. Go ahead.

Q Mr. President, what do you make of the images of people with guns, weapons showing up at the Michigan capitol?

THE PRESIDENT: Say it?

Q What do you make of the images of people with weapons showing up at the Michigan capitol to protest? Are you okay with that?

THE PRESIDENT: I haven’t seen it.

Q You haven’t seen those pictures?

THE PRESIDENT: You’ll have to — you’ll have to tell me.

Yeah, go ahead.

Q Should a vaccine be free?

THE PRESIDENT: We’re looking at that, actually. But we’re making a lot of progress on vaccines. But we’ll be speaking to you very soon, and I think we’re going to have a very good couple of meetings at Camp David.

Thank you.

END 5:07 P.M. EDT

Comey Briefed Clapper on Flynn-Kislyak Call as a Result of Pen Register on Flynn Phone…


First things first: ♦Understand Obama’s Surveillance Operation HERE.  ♦Michael Flynn wasn’t under a FISA (Title-1) HERE …. that’s the background.

The riddle of how the White House discovered the telephone call and subsequent content between Michael Flynn and Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak appears to have been solved. The FBI used a “Pen Register.”  There was no unmasking, and no warrant.

A pen register is a device/process which records the telephone numbers of outgoing calls.  Monitoring outgoing call numbers does not require a search warrant or FISA.

After the 2016 election Lt. Gen Flynn was given a government issued secure cell phone; a blackberry device for use.  However, with Flynn under a preexisting FBI investigation the phone numbers Flynn was calling in December ’16 and January ’17 were being monitored.

A review of prior testimony by former FBI Director James Comey [HERE]; prior testimony by former Deputy Director Andrew McCabe [Here]; and a cross-reference of recent releases of Flynn unmasking documents [Here] tells the full story.

In December of 2016 incoming National Security Advisor Michael Flynn was under a sketchy FBI Counterintelligence investigation for possible coordination with Russia.  According to recent documents and the Comey transcript, the Flynn investigation began in the summer of 2016; that investigation was ongoing in late December.

After President Obama initiated sanctions against Russia on December 29, 2016. The Obama administration was trying to figure out why Russia was not reacting.  According to James Comey testimony the intelligence community, writ large, was tasked to find out why Russia was not reacting more severely.  See Transcript:

Note:

…”And so we were all tasked to find out, do you have anything [redacted] that might reflect on this? That turned up these calls at the end of December, beginning of January.”

“do you have anything [redacted] that might reflect on this?”  Could pertain to the incoming administration, a person, or an intelligence capability.

However, to identify the “that“, we turn to the McCabe testimony (page 212):

…”in an effort to respond to the tasking from [REDACTED], and so the results of what we found were communicated to the Agency, who I think had the pen on that response.”

The individual or group initiating the task is redacted; however the redaction ends with the letter “f”, so it is most likely “redacted staff.”

Tasking from: NSC staff?  NCTC staff?  White House staff?

However, the other important facet is the “had the pen on that response.”  Meaning had the pen register responsibility on that response.

Pen Registers only monitor ‘outgoing‘ numbers.

It takes ‘trap and tracer’ authority to monitor the ‘incoming.’   Ambassador Kislyak was a foreign official whose surveillance would not require a pen register; however, a warrantless pen register would apply to Michael Flynn.  So the discovery of the contact reflects a review of Flynn’s calls; not just Kislyak (who can be monitored for any purpose).

The FBI discovers the contact via a pen register that was monitoring Flynn’s phone.  Then James Comey takes the information to DNI James Clapper.  Back to Comey transcript:

“And then I briefed it to the Director of National Intelligence, and Director Clapper asked me for copies [REDACTED] which I shared with him.”…

At this point it looks like James Comey uses the pen register to generate a non traditional intelligence product; perhaps a memo or rough draft of the transcript, or the pen register result itself; which, because of the content, contains Michael Flynn’s name.

Director Comey then shares with DNI Clapper.

Clapper then takes the document and uses it to brief President Obama.  This is how President Obama discovers the content of the call between Kislyak and Flynn:

The Clapper briefing of President Obama… likely happening prior to January 5th… using some non regular intelligence documentation…  is almost certainly the impetus for the unmasking request from President Obama’s Chief of Staff Denis McDonough which happened on January 5, 2017:

The January 5th unmasking request applies to a document about Flynn where Flynn’s name is unmasked.   That request is almost certainly the result of the White House receiving the official intelligence transcript of the Flynn-Kislyak call.  We know this because the non-traditional document that Comey gave to Clapper was not masked.

So the question becomes, what exactly was that ‘non-traditional’ intelligence document that Comey gave to Clapper to brief President Obama?

For that answer we go back to Andrew McCabe’s transcript as he described it (pg 213):

As you can see above McCabe describes the document as a “summary” of the call that “wasn’t an intelligence product”, and any unmasking would be unnecessary because Michael Flynn’s name within it was not masked.

That information flow is also why Lisa Page and Peter Strzok were saying “incidental collection” is the “incorrect narrative” in their text messages.  There was no unmasking because Flynn’s contact with Kislyak was not picked up as part of incidental collection, it was picked up because the FBI was using a pen registry to monitor all of Flynn’s contacts:

SUMMARY:  Flynn was under FBI investigation.  Per the IG report there was no FISA on Michael Flynn.  In the document generated by James Comey to share with DNI James Clapper,… to brief President Obama… Michael Flynn’s name was not masked.  The document was generated as a result of a pen register monitoring the outgoing contacts and phone numbers of Michael Flynn’s phone.

  • Flynn’s call was the subject of a “pen registry”.
  • Flynn’s device was government issued.
  • Flynn’s “outgoing” calls monitored without warrant.
  • Kislyak’s number was known.
  • The pen registry identified the specific calls from Flynn to Kislyak.
  • An “agency” provided the FBI with call content.
  • Comey provided call content (w/ a document) to James Clapper.
  • Clapper shared with White House during briefing.
  • No unmasking, no warrant, no FISA.

That’s how the White House got the call without unmasking request.