The History of Climate Change — Empires Fall When Warming Turns to Cooling


global-warming-cyclical

QUESTION:  Hi Martin I have a question I hope you can find time to answer. It appears we are heading into dark times with regards to the convergence of all of these cycles. We have government hunting every penny, we have civil war heating up between the left and right, we have revolution against government, international war and decreased solar activity. It seems everything is about to go bang all at once, has there been other periods in history when all of these cycles have converged as we are beginning to witness now on a global scale? Really fascinating stuff, and thank you.

Regards, John.

ANSWER: Oh yes. Here is a chart of the real data for global cyclical trends in the energy output of the sun and CO2 levels. Look at this chart prior to the Minoan warming. There was a very cold period a bit longer than 8,000 years ago — the Ice Age. You see what I would call a slingshot move when the temperatures swung sharply to a record high over about 300 years, according to the ice core samples. Thereafter, we move into a bear market, oscillating trend to retest the low made 4700 years ago. Then there is the steady rise into what we call the Minoan high.

Prior to the Minoan high, the temperature (climate change) was much more volatile. This is what drove the great migrations of humans around the globe if we assume they are correct and life began in Africa. This is the sharp swings that most likely resulted in frozen mammoths, lions, and woolly rhinoceros that were discovered in 1772. The warming up period into the Minoan high was really the birth of civilization/urbanization.

catal-huyuk

It was about 6700 BC when the earliest city appeared known by the name Catal Huyuk located in Turkey that covered about 30 acres. The buildings were of mud and brick construction, but inside there appeared plastered walls. No doubt, this was the latest modern invention that illustrates two important developments. First, this confirms the birth of an urban trade skill, and secondly, homes were found with paintings on the walls, suggesting the flourishing development of art — one of the last skills to develop within urban life reflecting good economic times.

The Minoan civilization was an Aegean Bronze Age civilization that arose on the island of Crete and other Aegean islands and flourished from approximately 3650 BC to 1400 BC. Clearly, sea travel must have emerged for the people to migrate from Turkey to Crete. Civilization appeared to emerge with this warming period. You then have the catastrophic eruption of Thera (Santorini), which may have been the largest known volcanic eruption within recorded history. That ended the Minoan civilization and gave rise to the plundering society of Mycenaean Greeks who conquered the Minoans and then Troy. But as weather turned colder, Greece, mostly rocky, entered its Dark Age and was unable to produce enough food. They became the Sea Peoples who invaded Northern Africa.

The climate changed again and began to warm, inspiring the rise of the Roman Empire. The warming trend allowed Julius Caesar (100-44 BC) to conquer and civilize Europe. The Roman Empire had three major climate changes known as the Early Subatlantic (900 BC–175 AD), Mid-Subatlantic (175–750 AD), and Late Subatlantic (since 750 AD). Written, archaeological evidence independently records that during the period of the Roman Empire’s maximum expansion and final crisis, the climate underwent drastic changes of cooling. During the reign of Trajan (98-117 AD), this was the peak in the territory occupied by the Roman Empire, which coincided with the Roman climatic peak in warming.

The climate change resulted in a sharp trend to a colder climate, which inspired the barbarian invasions (migration) into the Roman Empire where they moved south as the north grew severely colder. Historians imply that there were rapid fluctuations during the late empire after the reign of Trajan. We do have Seneca the Younger describing in 61 AD, a year before Nero ordered him to kill himself, the high level of air pollution in Rome associated with the extensive wood burning for fuel. This confirms there has always been pollution associated with cities.

The Roman Empire is considered to have peaked with the reign of Marcus Aureleus in 180 AD. That is where we draw the line for the beginning of the decline and fall of Rome. That is certainly the peak in the population of Rome itself. When the climate began to turn down, back into a strong cooling period, the fortunes of Rome also turned down. The evidence suggests that the Great Monetary collapse of Rome (around 180–290 AD), coincided with a sharp period of cooling. This seriously affected the northwestern provinces of the empire, especially in Germany and France, which clearly instigated the barbarian invasions of the south. We also have tree-rings dating (dendrochronology) from this period, which indicates there was a severe drought that began about 338 AD and persisted until 377 AD. This contributed to moving the capitol to Constantinople, which construction began about 324 AD when Constantine became the sole ruler.

The climate changed much colder in the north and sent the invasion of the Huns. The migration of the Huns, north of the Black Sea, drove the Goths to flee and press into the Roman Empire. The Roman Emperor Claudius II Gothicus (268-270 AD) was given that title for his defeat of the Goths. Climate change was a major driving force that led to the fall of the Western portion of the Roman Empire with the last Roman Emperor Romulus Augustus (475-476 AD). In the Eastern Roman Empire, climate change resulted in a regional prolonged drought from about 400—540 AD.

washington-delaware

The medieval warming was when the Dark Age of Europe began to light, giving birth to the Renaissance period. We begin to see the age of empire building when Spain, Portugal, Britain, and the Dutch all went off to the travel the world. We then begin to fall back into the last mini-Ice Age. We can see that the hard times led to revolution against monarchy in America and France. Paintings of the American Revolution illustrate how cold it really was with Washington crossing the iced Delaware River.

So unfortunately, when I say we have put everything into this model, I really mean what I say. When you put together the historical data, what pops out at you is just amazing. I had to gather coins from around the world to recreate the world monetary system and then place that on the timeline as well. What jumps out at you is the correlation of civilization and the rise and fall of empires with climate change.

Bruno Giordano burned at the stake Armstrong Economics

To have these charlatans schlep this bogus theory that man has created this global warming trend prevents real research. It is outrageous that these people have the audacity to want to make disagreeing with them a criminal act. I will not shut up, for these people are blocking a real investigation into how the world functions. I really would prefer death to living in this fake world that these horrible, pretend scientists are trying to create as Karl Marx did. These same types of people burned Giordano Bruno alive at the stake for saying that the Earth revolved around the Sun. If these people could, they would do this to me in a second.

 I welcome Trump's pick for the EPA - THIS IS DESPERATELY NEEDED!

Merkel Wants to Fully Censor the Internet Claiming Putin Wants Her Defeated


Putin 2020 World Expo

Merkel is already adopting the Obama strategy by blaming Putin for any potential loss in the election. She is going much further, perhaps because she grew up in Eastern Germany and sees no problem grabbing more power. Her party, the CDU , claims that the ambitions of Vladimir Putin are to defeat her in the elections this fall in the Bundestag, ignoring that the CDU has been coming in third place. Angela Merkel now says that disinformation is being sent over the internet to dethrone her. Therefore, the CDU wants full censorship in Germany and is planning to impose incredibly strict rules for all communication on the internet. She is claiming any negative news is really instigated by agents of Russia. That will probably include this site, despite the fact our model is not influenced by any human intervention, no less Putin.

The way sources are saying she is drafting this Draconian measure can even capture people who do not work for Merkel.  It seems that everyone prefers to blame Putin for losing an election rather than simply looking at their own actions. Therefore, the CDU wants to control all communications on the internet. In the United States, the CIA has classified some 200 websites as supporting Russia and have created a watch-list. These websites were then divided into two main categories: official Russian state media and “useful idiots.” This was done AFTER the election.

In Germany,  Michael Grosse-Brömer has accused Russia of planning to influence the election: “A departure from Merkel would be a success for Putin.” Exactly how that would benefit Putin is not clear. All governments are turning against their governments because they have grossly mismanaged the economy and the refugee crisis. Merely proclaiming that Putin is behind manipulations and disinformation in social networks is very easy to make and the press will support whatever the government tells them. 

Proposals are already circulating to impose financial penalties if a company does not immediately delete criminal content and hate speech. The SPD faction leader Thomas Oppermann has called for a serious action against Facebook, “I believe that Facebook has to be obligated to delete these, or to provide them with the same range as the fake representation, in the case of proven false declarations, invented messages.” Of course, hate-speech is very broad and can be applied to anyone who disagrees with the refugee policies. How can such censorship be applied on a global basis? Will all analysis of political and economic trends be deemed subversive?

The CDU is also targeting Google, which also operates the video platform Youtube. After all, it was the BREXIT movie that was on YouTube. The CDU says it is unacceptable and that YouTube cannot control in advance what people see. There are those in European politics that are now advocating full-blown censorship fearing the collapse of the EU as well. There seems to be a movement to deny the right to the truth or free speech brewing under the pretense that they claim it is Putin.

deutsche-welle

What happens if the BBC operated by the British government does a negative piece of Merkel? In Germany, the Deutsche Welle is directly subordinated to the Chancellor’s Office. State propaganda is acceptable, but anyone who disagrees is somehow now an agent of Putin. This is one of the last rungs a government breaks before it becomes the enemy of the people.

 

Frontrunning: December 15


Tyler Durden's picture
  • Yellen, Trump on the Same Page, for Now (WSJ)
  • Bond Rout Deepens After Fed Move (WSJ)
  • Dollar Climbs to Strongest Since 2003 on Fed Path; Bonds Drop (BBG)
  • Trump’s $6 Billion Cabinet: Mostly Men, Mostly White and Not Much Government Experience (BBG)
  • Trump’s Foreign Partners Expect to Benefit (WSJ)
  • Targeting U.S. automaker signals possible China retaliation over Trump talk (Reuters)
  • Chinese ambassador to U.S.: Sovereignty not a ‘bargaining chip’ (Reuters)
  • Italy ready to recapitalise ailing banks with 15 billion euros: (Reuters)
  • China Halts Trading in Key Bond Futures (WSJ)
  • Inside the BOJ, rate hikes are back on the radar. Really (Reuters)
  • Assad’s Choice: Fight Rebels but Give Way to ISIS (WSJ)
  • OPEC Threatened by a Tiny Oklahoma Town (BBG)
  • Russia says talks with U.S. over Aleppo suspended (Reuters)
  • Tokyo Regains Costliest City for Expats Title as London Drops (BBG)
  • SNB Joins Draghi in Warning of Dread for Politics Next Year (BBG)
  • Google extends conservative outreach as Trump calls tech meeting (Reuters)
  • Iran sanctions extension act to become law without Obama’s signature: White House (Reuters)
  • Stolen Yahoo Data Includes Government Employee Information (BBG)
  • $2 Billion Gulfport Buy Shows Drillers Thirsting for Next Play (BBG)
  • Average Credit Card Debt: $16K. Total Debt: $133K. Where Do You Fit In? (BBG)

 

Overnight Media Digest

WSJ

THE GLOBE AND MAIL

** Ethics Commissioner Mary Dawson has decided to question Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau formally to determine whether he breached the Conflict of Interest Act when he attended Liberal Party cash-for-access fundraisers with corporate executives wanting favors from the federal government. https://tgam.ca/2h3yVcG

** The federal Liberal government will bow to a recommendation of a Senate committee that is reviewing legislation to end gender-based discrimination in the Indian Act by asking the Quebec Superior Court – which said the act had to be corrected by early February – for an extension to allow more time for consultation. https://tgam.ca/2gMxHqg

** A plan to lift Stelco Inc out of creditor protection is backed by the Ontario government and one of the steel maker’s union locals, but another union local, the city of Hamilton and a former president of the company oppose the proposal. https://tgam.ca/2hzDN9T

NATIONAL POST

** Canada is committing to public consultations on a potential free trade deal with China, and government officials from both countries are set to hold a first meeting early in 2017. http://bit.ly/2gCAPzK

** In a surprising move Wednesday, Evernote said it will be updating its privacy policy next month to allow employees to physically see data users upload to its service. http://bit.ly/2hwHPmk

** The Canadian federal government hopes its corporate governance bill will improve gender diversity on corporate boards, but won’t rule out quotas if the problem persists, innovation minister Navdeep Bains said Wednesday. http://bit.ly/2hohvdB

 

FT

– Spanish Healthcare group Grifols is buying the nucleic acid testing unit of Hologic for $1.85 billion. Deal includes a plant in San Diego along with development rights and licenses to patents and access to product manufacturers.

– New York Stock Exchange agreed to buy the National Stock Exchange. It also agreed to keep the National Stock exchange open. The deal will give the exchanges operator a fourth U.S. exchange licence and one that would be distinct from NYSE, NYSE MKT and Arca.

– Struggling internet giant Yahoo said hackers stole personal data on more than a billion users in 2013. This announcement comes after the summer’s disclosure of another intrusion in 2014 that affected 500 million Yahoo accounts.

– Darren Woods, former head of its refining and transport operations, was appointed as Exxon Mobil’s new chief executive, following the retirement of Rex Tillerson who has been picked by Donald Trump to be his secretary of state.

– Uber has been ordered by California highways regulator to pull its self-driving cars off the roads of San Francisco while it obtains the required permit, less than a day after it began the pilot in its hometown

 

NYT

– Yahoo Inc, already reeling from its September disclosure that 500 million user accounts had been hacked in 2014, disclosed Wednesday that a different attack in 2013 compromised more than 1 billion accounts. The two attacks are the largest known security breaches of one company’s computer network. http://nyti.ms/2hQbcMV

– The U.S. Federal Reserve raised its benchmark interest rate Wednesday for just the second time since the financial crisis of 2008, saying the American economy is expanding at a healthy pace and setting itself up as a counterweight to President-elect Donald Trump’s push for considerably faster growth. http://nyti.ms/2hvQwNM

– President-elect Donald Trump met with Jeff Bezos of Amazon.com Inc and Timothy Cook of Apple Inc, among other tech leaders, in a surprisingly genial gathering. http://nyti.ms/2gNeRO3

– Fox News named Kevin Lord as the new head of human resources in the aftermath of a sexual harassment scandal that led to the ousting of the network’s chairman and exposed a culture of inappropriate behavior toward women. http://nyti.ms/2hQc6ZZ

– Exxon Mobil Corp wasted no time in announcing on Wednesday that Darren Woods, the company president, would succeed Rex Tillerson as chairman and chief executive now that Tillerson has been nominated to head the State Department. http://nyti.ms/2hHyclh

– Warner Bros streamlined its film operation on Wednesday, consolidating filmmaking power under Toby Emmerich and parting ways with Greg Silverman, a move that comes after a highly profitable but creatively inconsistent stretch for the studio. http://nyti.ms/2hvStd2

– Uber made a big splash in its hometown on Wednesday when it started offering self-driving car service to passengers here, making San Francisco the second city in the world where the ride-hailing company provides autonomous vehicles for public use. http://nyti.ms/2hyatAP

 

Canada

THE GLOBE AND MAIL

** Ethics Commissioner Mary Dawson has decided to question Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau formally to determine whether he breached the Conflict of Interest Act when he attended Liberal Party cash-for-access fundraisers with corporate executives wanting favors from the federal government. https://tgam.ca/2h3yVcG

** The federal Liberal government will bow to a recommendation of a Senate committee that is reviewing legislation to end gender-based discrimination in the Indian Act by asking the Quebec Superior Court – which said the act had to be corrected by early February – for an extension to allow more time for consultation. https://tgam.ca/2gMxHqg

** A plan to lift Stelco Inc out of creditor protection is backed by the Ontario government and one of the steel maker’s union locals, but another union local, the city of Hamilton and a former president of the company oppose the proposal. https://tgam.ca/2hzDN9T

NATIONAL POST

** Canada is committing to public consultations on a potential free trade deal with China, and government officials from both countries are set to hold a first meeting early in 2017. http://bit.ly/2gCAPzK

** In a surprising move Wednesday, Evernote said it will be updating its privacy policy next month to allow employees to physically see data users upload to its service. http://bit.ly/2hwHPmk

** The Canadian federal government hopes its corporate governance bill will improve gender diversity on corporate boards, but won’t rule out quotas if the problem persists, innovation minister Navdeep Bains said Wednesday. http://bit.ly/2hohvdB

 

Britain

The Times

* Twenty-First Century Fox Inc is expected today to make a formal offer to buy Sky Plc in an 18.5 billion pounds ($23.17 billion) takeover. http://bit.ly/2hH1dO7

* Mortgage lending dipped in October for home movers, first-time buyers and buy-to-let landlords, according to the Council for Mortgage Lenders. The Council said a total of 10.5 billion pounds ($13.15 billion) had been lent in October. This was 11 percent lower than October last year. http://bit.ly/2hGTxeO

The Guardian

* The Danish firm Lego is to raise its prices in Britain by 5 percent next year as it becomes the latest manufacturer to respond to the plunging pound after the UK voted to leave the EU. http://bit.ly/2hGUync

* The maximum compensation someone can receive if an investment company goes bust could be increased from its current 50,000 pounds ($62,610.00) to as much as 1 million pounds ($1.25 million), Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority has suggested. http://bit.ly/2hGWD2p

The Telegraph

* It is vital to fight for the City London in the Brexit negotiations, and the government should not be ashamed to stand up for Britain’s banking expertise, a committee of Lords has announced. http://bit.ly/2hGQeUV

* The London Stock Exchange Group Plc has said it will “constructively engage” with European regulators after they homed in on derivatives clearing as the focus of their probe into the firm’s planned merger with Deutsche Boerse. http://bit.ly/2hGVojs

Sky News

* A strike by drivers who deliver goods for Argos Resources Ltd has been called off just a day after it was announced. http://bit.ly/2hGTgsd

* The architect of impending reforms to the BBC’s governance, David Clementi, is among a crop of candidates vying to become the broadcaster’s next chairman. http://bit.ly/2hGVzeI

The Independent

* British Airways cabin crew have voted in favour of strikes which could severely impact flights at Heathrow airport over Christmas. http://ind.pn/2hGVHuY

* Conditions at a JD Sports Fashion Plc’s warehouse are “worse than a prison” and staff are threatened with being sacked just for sitting down, according to allegations made in a Channel 4 News film. http://ind.pn/2hGNmYa

 

Dollar Surges, Yields Soar, Euro Tumbles To 13 Year Low As Markets React To Hawkish Fed


Tyler Durden's picture

This morning the world awakes to a landscape in which markets are frantically rushing to catch up to a suddenly hawkish Fed which not only hiked for the second time in a decade but, as per yesterday’s Fed statement and Yellen press conference, realized it has been behind the curve all along, and the result has been a spike in the dollar across virtually all currency pairs with the USDJPY surging above 118.40, coupled with a jump in bond yields around the globe as bond (the US 10 Year is trading at 2.64%, the highest since September 2014) as traders dump any hint of duration.

The sentiment was notable in the analyst commentary this morning:

  • “The Fed is becoming a leopard with new spots,” said Stephen Gallo, currency analyst at BMO Capital Markets in London. “The Fed has shifted its 2017 bias away from supporting growth with ultra-stimulative policies towards keeping a lid on inflation risk.”
  • “Maybe Fed officials are more concerned about the prospects for a rise in inflation next year than they are letting on, given the potential boost a fiscal stimulus could bring, which was something they didn’t have to consider last year,” Michael Hewson, a market analyst at CMC Markets in London, wrote in a note.
  • “You had the Fed come in and be a bit more hawkish that many people, including us, were expecting,” said TD Securities head of global strategy Richard Kelly. “It wasn’t just the move in the dots, it was the language that was used. There was an acknowledgement that if Trump gets his plans moving through congress you could see the economy pushing higher.”

DB’s Jim Reid had a different angle: it will be all about the volatility in rates in the coming year, as the Fed has officially unleashed the inflationary genie out of the bottle.

People in my profession have perhaps been guilty of over analysing the Fed in recent years when every small nuance was over examined when in reality they really haven’t done much over this period. However last night’s statement and press conference was full of interesting remarks and certainly landed on the hawkish side with the dots edging up with the median dot now showing 3 hikes for 2017 rather than 2 beforehand. Last night’s meeting broke a trend as prior to this, the last six FOMCs have seen treasury yields fall with the last seven seeing the dollar fall against the Euro. Not this time. The meeting fits in with our view that markets are vulnerable to a bond yield spike next year. Rates vol could be the main talking point of 2017.

In equities, after yesterday’s drop, the biggest since the election, Asian stocks fell but European equities rose driven by financials while S&P futures are already getting the BTFD treatment and trying to make up for Thursday’s drop .

It wasn’t just the Fed tightening monetary policy. Shortly after the Fed announcement, virtually all Gulf Arab states followed suit out of necessity to keep their dollar pegs. As Bloomberg notes, policy makers in Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, Bahrain and Qatar raised borrowing costs within hours after the Fed raised its benchmark rate for the first time this year. The prospect of further increases in U.S. rates next year will complicate efforts to bolster economic growth and ease a cash squeeze among Gulf banks as revenue from oil exports, the region’s main source of income, plummets.

However, while stocks are modestly higher, the big story this morning is all about the Dollar, which continues its relentless surge higher, in the process pushing the USDJPY, as the Yen tumbles over 1%, and sending the pair to 118.30, the highet level since the start of the year…

… but more notably the Euro, which moments ago also plunged by 1% to 1.043, dropping to the lowest level since January 2003.

The dollar also extended its advance against all major and emerging-market peers.

The bloodbath was not confined to FX, however, as global government bonds were left reeling this morning, with the 10Y Treasury spiking to 2.64%, the highest level in over two years, while European bonds likewise tumbled, sending 10Y yields surging as follows:

  • Spain +6bps at 1.46%;
  • Italy +6bps at 1.85%,
  • Portugal +4bps at 3.82%,
  • German +7bps at 0.37%;
  • Dec. bund futures -95 ticks at 161.51

This all follows this morning record crash in Chinese bond futures, which sent local 10Y yields higher by 22 bps, the most on record, to 3.45%, as a plunging yuan and hawkish Fed comments damped expectations of monetary easing in China.

 

In early trading, stocks were ignoring the momentous moves in FX and rates, and for now stocks in Europe and US futures traded higher, with the Stoxx Europe 600 Index rising 0.3 percent, led by banks.Randgold Resources Ltd., Fresnillo Plc and Centamin Plc fell more than 7 percent with declines in precious metals, while Electricite de France SA sank the most on record after saying profit will drop next year. The VStoxx Index declined 9 percent to the lowest level since September 2014, signaling traders are pulling back from hedging against swings in euro area shares.

In the U.S., futures on the S&P 500 Index were up about 0.2% after the equity gauge posted its biggest loss in two months on Wednesday, however should the bond collapse continue we fear the green will quickly shift to red.

* * *

Bulletin Headline Summary From RanSquawk

  • European bourses enter the North American crossover higher with financials outperforming
  • USD strength remains the key theme in FX markets with USD/JPY remaining north of 118.00
  • Looking ahead, highlights include SNB, Norges Bank, BoE rate decisions, US CPI, Philadelphia Mfg Index, NY Empire and Weekly Jobs

Market Snapshot:

  • S&P 500 futures up less than 0.2% to 2255.2
  • Stoxx 600 up 0.2% to 356
  • FTSE 100 down 0.2% to 6934
  • DAX up 0.5% to 11302
  • German 10Yr yield up 7bps to 0.37%
  • Italian 10Yr yield up 5bps to 1.84%
  • Spanish 10Yr yield up 5bps to 1.45%
  • S&P GSCI Index up 0.1% to 391.5
  • MSCI Asia Pacific down 1.7% to 136
  • Nikkei 225 up 0.1% to 19274
  • Hang Seng down 1.8% to 22059
  • Shanghai Composite down 0.7% to 3118
  • S&P/ASX 200 down 0.8% to 5539
  • US 10-yr yield up 2bps to 2.59%
  • Dollar Index up 0.67% to 102.44
  • WTI Crude futures up 0.4% to $51.23
  • Brent Futures up 0.8% to $54.33
  • Gold spot down 0.4% to $1,138
  • Silver spot down 1.7% to $16.56

Global Headlines

  • Molina CEO Tells Aetna-Humana Judge Company Isn’t ‘Trivial’
  • Exxon Names Darren Woods as New CEO to Replace Rex Tillerson
  • Laureate Said to Raise Over $300 Million From Apollo, Abraaj
  • Lonza Focuses on Health With $5.5 Billion Deal for Capsugel
  • Dubai Said to Plan $36 Billion Spend on World’s Biggest Airport

Asian equity markets traded mostly negative as the region reacted to the FOMC rate decision and steeper projected rate path. This pressured US stocks and dampened bourses across Asia with ASX 200 (-0.8%) led lower by commodity names after around 4%-5% declines in oil and iron ore, while gold slumped around USD 20. Hang Seng (-1.8%) and Shanghai Comp. (-0.7%) were also weighed by the developments across the Pacific and as regulators continued to impact risk appetite, with the CIRC seeking to lower the total proportion of equity assets held by insurance funds to 30% from 40%. Nikkei 225 (+0.4%) outperformed as downside pressure was overshadowed by JPY weakness which resulted to firm gains in large auto names, while 10yr JGBs saw spill-over selling from T-notes and fell below 150.00 as yields rose across the curve in reaction to the prospects of a steeper Fed rate hike path. However, prices were off worst levels following a 20yr JGB auction in which the b/c increased from prior and tail in price narrowed. PBoC injected CNY 140bIn 7-day reverse repos, CNY 45bIn in 14-day reverse repos, CNY 60bIn in 28-day reverse repos.

Top Asian News

  • Indonesia Keeps Benchmark Rate Unchanged as Rupiah Slumps on Fed: Decision was forecast by all but one of 21 economists surveyed
  • China Deploying Weapons on Artificial Reefs, Think Tank Says: China appears to be deploying weapons systems on all seven of the reefs it has reclaimed in the South China Sea, according to Washington-based Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative
  • Japan Said to Assess Risks Tied to Banks’ Treasury Holdings: FSA said to survey banks on their U.S. bond portfolios
  • Top Nickel Shipper Drags Out Mining Audit as Lopez Holds On: Final results of checkup are now due in January, Philippines Environment Secretary Gina Lopez says
  • Goldman’s Logistics Spat Fast-Tracked in Test for Indian Courts: Commercial court in Telangana to begin hearing case against an Indian logistics company on Dec. 29

European markets trade higher as analysts and traders digests the key points from last night’s FOMC rate decision. Financials are outperforming at the top of the leader boards with 3 rate hikes touted for next year. The materials sector is feeling the pinch after the stronger dollar and low gold prices take their toll. In equity specific news Lonza Group (LONN VX) have confirmed they are to buy Capsugel for USD 5.5bIn this sent shares tumbling to the bottom of the SMI down as much as 10%. Fixed income markets have seen prices fall dramatically at the start of the session, Bunds currently trade near session lows at around 161.58 but north of the contract low seen at 159.91. This was largely inline with the moves seen in the T-Notes after the FOMC statement. Gilts are also underperforming down 120 ticks but we could also see some more volatility with the BoE also today. Note a full preview is available on our headline feed.

Top European News

  • EDF Sees Ebitda Falling to EU13.7b-EU14.3b in 2017
  • Metro Group to Demerge, Split Into Two Separate Companies
  • Lonza to Buy Capsugel for $5.5b
  • H&M Sales Miss Estimates in November, 4Q
  • SNB Joins Draghi in Warning of Dread for 2017 Political Calendar
  • VW Posts First Europe Market-Share Gain Since Diesel Crisis

In currencies, the dollar gained 0.5 percent to $1.0486 per euro as of 10:38 a.m. London time. A move through $1.0458 would make the greenback the strongest since 2003. The U.S. currency climbed 1 percent against the yen, reaching the highest level since February. The Fed lifted its target for overnight borrowing costs by 25 basis points, or 0.25 percentage point, on Wednesday to a range of 0.5 percent to 0.75 percent. Policy makers expect three rate increases in 2017, up from the two seen in September.

In commodities, gold for immediate delivery was down 0.4 percent to $1,137.79 an ounce, sliding to its lowest price since February. The commodity has lost 14 percent since the end of September. West Texas Intermediate crude was up 0.5 percent at $51.28 a barrel, after Wednesday’s 3.7 percent slide. Libya is preparing this week to ship the first cargo from its largest export terminal in two years.

Looking at the day ahead, the main highlight data wise will likely be the November inflation report. The market is expecting headline CPI to increase +0.2% mom and the core to also increase +0.2% mom, a view also shared by our US economists. Meanwhile, the latest weekly initial jobless claims data will be out alongside Empire manufacturing and the Philly Fed manufacturing reports for December. Lastly the NAHB housing market index reading will be out too. Away from the data, Japan PM Abe and Russia President Putin are scheduled to hold a meeting aimed at proposing economic cooperation between the two countries. The ECB will also publish the net take-up for TLTRO II. Finally EU leaders are also due to gather to discuss migration and security issues, as well as debate the Brexit process in Brussels this morning.

US Event Calendar

  • 8:30am: Current Account Balance, 3Q, est. -$111.6b (prior – $119.9b)
  • 8:30am: Empire Manufacturing, Dec., est. 4 (prior 1.5)
  • 8:30am: CPI m/m, Nov., est. 0.2% (prior 0.4%)
  • 8:30am: Initial Jobless Claims, Dec. 10, est. 255k (prior 258k)
  • 8:30am: Philadelphia Fed Business Outlook, Dec., est. 9.1 (prior 7.6)
  • 9:45am: Bloomberg Consumer Comfort, Dec. 11 (prior 45.1)
  • 9:45am: Markit U.S. Manufacturing PMI, Dec. P, est. 54.5 (prior 54.1)
  • 10am: Freddie Mac mortgage rates
  • 10:30am: Bank of Canada’s Poloz speaks in Ottawa
  • 10:30am: EIA natural-gas storage change

* * *
 

DB’s Jim reid concludes the overnight wrap

People in my profession have perhaps been guilty of over analysing the Fed in recent years when every small nuance was over examined when in reality they really haven’t done much over this period. However last night’s statement and press conference was full of interesting remarks and certainly landed on the hawkish side with the dots edging up with the median dot now showing 3 hikes for 2017 rather than 2 beforehand. Last night’s meeting broke a trend as prior to this, the last six FOMCs have seen treasury yields fall with the last seven seeing the dollar fall against the Euro. Not this time. The meeting fits in with our view that markets are vulnerable to a bond yield spike next year. Rates vol could be the main talking point of 2017.

The first takeaway was some of the subtle tweaks in the tone of the statement. The committee highlighted the “considerable” pickup in inflation compensation and also the “decline” in the unemployment rate. Risks were still referenced as being “roughly balanced” which is something DB’s Peter Hooper believes is the committee’s way of recognising the fact that risks may never be perfectly balanced. Meanwhile, there was a subtle shift in the way the committee recognises how accommodative policy is now, toning down the extent to which it is accommodative by adding “some” to the observation that it is enough to support some further strengthening in the labour market. The signalling of a gradual pace of rate hikes was left as is.

The dots caused the most excitement however. As highlighted at the top the median dot for 2017 rose to 3 hikes from 2. In fact the number of committee members now forecasting just 2 hikes or less next year is only 6 out of 17. It had been 10 committee members at the last forecast. In other words 4 committee members shifted to 3 or more hikes. So a fairly convincing move. The 2018 and 2019 median dots were left at 3 hikes apiece while the longer run dot moved back to 3% after having been split between 2.75% and 3.0% last time out. Economic projections were a bit more of a non-event with growth and inflation forecasts revised up slightly and unemployment revised down.

Fed Chair Yellen’s press conference offered the final few interesting snippets. She made special mention in particular to the change in the dots being “really very tiny” which was seen as her way of softening the hawkishness of them. She also added that she never said that she favoured “running a high pressure” economy and wanted to make it clear that she has “not recommended running a hot economy as some sort of experiment”. A reminder that back in October Yellen had said at a speech in Boston that there might be benefits to temporarily letting the economy run hot with robust aggregate demand and a tight labour market to reverse adverse supply side effects. Meanwhile, when asked about fiscal stimulus Yellen said that “fiscal policy is not obviously needed to provide stimulus to help us get back to full employment”. When asked about the Fed’s response to fiscal, DB’s Peter Hooper highlighted that she did not explicitly say they would raise rates faster, but rather left that implicit in her response.

In terms of the market the immediate reaction function came in rates where the Treasury curve bear flattened in response. 10y yields smashed through 2.50% to close up +9.9bps on the day at 2.572% which is the highest since September 2014. 5y Treasury yields went through 2% and closed +13.9bps higher on the day at 2.049% which is the highest since April 2011. 2y yields finished up +10.4bps at 1.269% and the highest since August 2009. Futures also moved to price in a bit more than 2 rate hikes by December 2017. Also noticeable was the 2y Bund/Treasury spread which has now blown out to 205bps and the widest since 2000 while the 10y Bund/Treasury spread hit 227bps and is, amazingly, the widest since 1989. Currency markets weren’t to be ruled out with the US Dollar index touching highs last seen in 2003. That came largely at the expense of emerging market currencies which plummeted anywhere from -1% to -2%. Risk assets suffered meanwhile. The S&P 500 (-0.81%) had its worst day since October 11th while credit spreads finished wider with CDX IG nearly 2bps wider by the end of play. In commodities Gold (-1.35%) tumbled below $1150/oz while WTI Oil, weighed down by the rally for the USD and also some bearish supply data in the US, plummeted -3.66% and back to $51/bbl.

This morning in Asia the bond sell-off has continued with benchmark 10y yields in the antipodeans 10-11bps higher and 10y JGB yields also back up +2.5bps to 0.073%. Equity markets have followed the Wall Street lead and retreated. The Nikkei (-0.15%), Hang Seng (-1.69%), Shanghai Comp (-0.29%), Kospi (-0.04%) and ASX (-0.62%) all down. In credit the iTraxx Asia is 4bps wider currently.

Moving on. Today brings another central bank into focus with the BoE MPC meeting outcome due around midday. Both the market and our economists expect no surprises with current policy settings to stay as is. Indeed our economists expect the BoE to maintain the broadly neutral stance that they adopted at the November MPC meeting. Firstly, they highlight that the economy appears to be holding up well and consensus expectations for 2017 GDP growth have risen to 1.3%, albeit no higher than the MPC’s own forecast (1.4%). Secondly, sterling’s recent appreciation may reduce peak inflation marginally, although there is still a net 15% depreciation relative to late 2015 and recent data shows increasing evidence of pass through into core goods prices. Ultimately our colleagues think that the MPC will not rush to judgement this week and the neutral bias will remain. Their baseline view is that UK monetary policy won’t change in 2017 and sovereign QE will be allowed to end in Q1. However, with the real income shock coming they see a higher probability of the next move being an easing rather than a tightening.

Staying in the UK, yesterday Brexit Secretary David Davis spoke and didn’t rule out the possibility of a transitional deal ‘if necessary’ as a kind of ‘bridge’ for the UK leaving the EU. Putting him more on side with Chancellor Hammond, Davis also indicated that ‘an implementation phase’ could be a possibility. He also noted that the Government will not reveal Brexit plans before February. In any case the overall rhetoric from Davis clearly favours the recent move towards a softer exit. Sterling had initially been as much as half a percent stronger before the post-FOMC Dollar rally saw the Pound finish weaker.
Before we look at the day ahead, it was also a fairly busy day for economic data yesterday. In the US the primary focus was on the November retail sales report. Headline sales were up less than expected during the month (+0.1% mom vs. +0.3% expected) while the ex auto and gas component was also softer than expected (+0.2% mom vs. +0.4% expected). The GDP-sensitive control group component also missed (+0.1% mom vs. +0.3% expected) which will likely create some downside risks to Q4 GDP although by now the focus may have already turned to 2017 growth. Meanwhile there was also some softness in last month’s industrial production print (-0.4% mom vs. -0.3% expected) with capacity utilization also declining four-tenths to 75.0%. Elsewhere, producer prices were reported as rising more than expected. Headline PPI rose to +0.4% mom (vs. +0.1% expected) helping to raise the YoY rate to +1.3% from +0.8%.

In the UK the ILO unemployment rate was reported as holding steady in October at 4.8% although employment did decline a modest 6k with the statistics office noting that the labour market ‘appears to have flattened off in recent months’. There was better news in the earnings data however with average weekly earnings rising one-tenth to +2.5% yoy. Ex-bonuses rose to +2.6% yoy which is the fastest pace since August last year. Finally in France there were no last minute surprises in the November CPI report with consumer prices reported as unchanged during the month. For completeness in markets yesterday, European equity markets were generally weaker across the board with the Stoxx 600 finishing -0.50% prior to the Fed. Sovereign bond markets were firmer, albeit also pre-Fed clearly.

Looking at the day ahead the early focus in Europe this morning is on the December flash PMI’s where we’ll get manufacturing, services and composite readings. In the UK we’ll also get more data in the form of the November retail sales numbers while around midday the focus then turns over to the BoE MPC meeting outcome. No change in policy is expected there. Later on in the US the main highlight data wise will likely be the November inflation report. The market is expecting headline CPI to increase +0.2% mom and the core to also increase +0.2% mom, a view also shared by our US economists. Meanwhile, the latest weekly initial jobless claims data will be out alongside Empire manufacturing and the Philly Fed manufacturing reports for December. Lastly the NAHB housing market index reading will be out too. Away from the data, Japan PM Abe and Russia President Putin are scheduled to hold a meeting aimed at proposing economic cooperation between the two countries. The ECB will also publish the net take-up for TLTRO II. Finally EU leaders are also due to gather to discuss migration and security issues, as well as debate the Brexit process in Brussels this morning.

A REAL JOURNALIST WARNS US WWIII WITH RUSSIA, CHINA IS ALREADY UNDERWAY


The nuclear weapons have been out here since the 50’s — China has grown significantly over the past 20 twenty some years and now has a world presence that didn’t exist before. Now they need the worlds raw materials to support their production so they also want to protect their shipping and that brings them into conflict with others. Most of this is because of Obama downsizing the army which projects weakness — so we are where we are and trump will need to deal with it!

Sweden tells municipalities to prepare for war


Sweden has already been invaded by the Muslims it way to late for them!

Nigel Farage Blasts EU Refusal to Accept “Democracy and the Rebirth of The Nation State”…


Mr. Nigel Farage, MEP (Member of European Parliament), spoke earlier today in Brussels. Farage warned, yet again, about the contradiction of a supposed ‘democratic body’ (the EU) refusi…

Source: Nigel Farage Blasts EU Refusal to Accept “Democracy and the Rebirth of The Nation State”…

And in the EU the same thing drain their swamp.

trump-drain-the-swamp12111111111111211111111111111111111111211111111111111111111111111211112

Fed Raises Rates Quarter Point


FederalReserve-1

The Fed raised the interest rate a quarter-point increase in the discount, or primary credit, rate, from 1 percent to 1.25 percent, and moved its target range from a range of 0.25 percent to 0.5 percent to 0.5 percent to 0.75 percent. The overnight funds rate currently sits at 0.41 percent.

The Fed was citing the steady growth of the American economy. The Fed did not give any indication that the election of Donald J. Trump has altered its economic outlook saying it still expected a slow economic expansion. The Fed also implied that it would continue a gradual advance toward higher rates and that they expected to raise rates three times in 2017. Of course, they said that for 2016 as well.

The decision was taken by a unanimous vote of the 10 members of the Federal Open Market Committee. This was actually the first time in recent months the Fed has acted by consensus. The Fed also said it expected that the economy still needed help. Its economic outlook remained unchanged from September. Fed officials continued to predict the economy would expand at an annual rate of about 2 percent for the next few years.

However, we see asset inflation from capital inflows. This will support the dollar and the US share market. The Dow has penetrated yesterday’s low and a close below that should give a pull-back. Gold fell to new lows trading at 1149 and Crude oil dropped from $54 to $50. The euro is also poised to break to new recent lows.

Europe Starting to Break Apart


juncker

You can tell that Europe is breaking apart because the EU has gone too far. EU President Jean-Claude Juncker has warned against attempts to undermine or dissolve the European Union. “Those who believe that it is time to divide, dismember and divide the EU into national divisions are completely wrong,” said Juncker in Maastricht, the Netherlands. Europe would lose its importance economically and populously in international comparison he argued. “We will not exist as a single country without the European Union.”

That statement makes it very clear that those in Brussels want a federalized Europe and see their role as managing “a single country.” Therein lies all the problem. The EU abandoned its economic union and wanted a political union of one country. That was the same dream of Hitler and Napoleon.

Do People Hear Only What They Want to Hear?


Manipulation-Markets

QUESTION: You always say the markets cannot be manipulated. Deutsche Bank is turning over the smoking gun. Any comment?

ANSWER: It seems you are using the term “manipulation” extremely loosely. You are mixing this term up with collusion and coordination, yes with the intent to “move” a market within the immediate trend which is not “manipulation” as it is being thrown around. Front-running and pressing or spoofing a market does not translate into systemically suppressing a market to prevent it from ever rallying for decades. Nobody does that and it would produce no instant profit. All the emails and text messages in the Deutsche Bank released illustrate collusion and coordinated events to press the market within the immediate trend. They do not show systemic perpetual manipulation. Here is what I wrote in Behind The Curtain back in 2009. The information now surfacing from the Deutsche Bank files confirms what I wrote about years ago:


Look Behind the Curtain, April 9, 2009.

During the late 1970s, the silver market was claimed to be “cornered” by the Hunt Brothers. That was far from true, for what they failed to understand, was that the attitude of the major brokerage houses was not that you were a pure trader-customer, but someone to pick – off for profit. During the 1980s, I had to take on some hedging projects that were awesome. One was in platinum. When you are the largest trader in a narrow market, they watch everything you do. If I was to sell, they assume the whole lot is being sold and jump in front. You suddenly find yourself trapped. I was a witness to the Hunt collapse. They couldn’t get out of the market at any price. The dealers were selling in front of them taking short positions looking to buy back when the Hunts were in a state of panic dumping at any price.

I learned early on that to professionally hedge, one had to navigate the brokers. The only way to deal with them, was to play one-off-against-another, use related markets to confuse and hide your strategy, or else fall prey to the Investment Bankers. In other words, if you had a large position of gold that you wanted to sell, you go to a broker asking for a market in silver. He gives you a quote, and you then buy taking what will become an intentional loss. You go back to the same broker and now ask for a quote on the real market you are trying to sell – gold. He will anticipate you intend to buy because of the silver trade, shifting the quotes to pick up extra profit assuming you are a buyer. When you sell the gold, you just got a higher bid, you are out of the position, and he is scrambling to cover with other brokers. If you hit all the brokers the same way at precisely the same time, they are all now short, and are trapped trying to get out selling back gold that they just bought from you trying to play you for the fool.

These games are at times necessary in the cash markets because the brokers themselves are not satisfied with just making a real market. They need to create an edge. So when you are the 800 pound gorilla, you need defensive measures. It helps to understand the method to the madness of the game.

The market manipulations that really began back in the 70’s with force,became intermixed among the Investment Bankers with technology. we began to see grouping of houses by the later 1980s and early 1990s. Perhaps at first, they were looking for another Hunt. They needed to sell some billionaire on the virtues of cornering and manipulating a market.

The first real coordinated scheme began back in 1993 that I could verify. The target market was silver, and the central player, broker-dealer, was Phillips Brothers who were a big commodity outfit in Connecticut, picked up by Salomon Brothers who was later absorbed as well. This ms known as PhiBro of the same fame relating to Marc Rich.

PhiBro had a huge client who they were acting for to buy up the silver market in 1993. This was an aggressive professional strategy. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission could easily see where the buying was centered in real force. They went to PhiBro demanding to know who their client was. PhiBro refused to give up the name. The CFTC ordered PhiBro to just get out of the market. They did. They just dumped everything at the market wiping out small investors in the blink of an eye.

The CFTC just walked away. Had this been a small broker or money manager, he would have been criminally prosecuted. But the CFTC is notorious for never even once bringing a complaint against a major house. The sources I relied upon, gave me the name of the client – Warren Buffett. Based upon this information and belief, when his name came up again in 1997, it is not a shock.

We kept track of what the “club” was doing and warned our clients whenever their antics were conflicting. One of the big ones that blew the lid off, was again silver. In 1997, I warned that silver was going to rise from $4 to $7 between September and January 1998. I was even invited to join them, and told to stop fighting, and put out false forecasts. I declined. Their strategy became insane.

At first, a friend of mine who had been Prime Minister Thatcher’s economic advisor became a board member of AIG in London. He called one day and asked if he could drop in to Princeton the next morning when he arrived from London. I naturally said OK. To my surprise, he arrived with the head trader from AIG London who then proceeded to try to convince me to stop talking about the manipulations. I told him I would not ever reveal any names, and the government didn’t care anyway.

Things got insane thereafter. An analyst on the payroll of PhiBro had a main contact at the Wall Street Journal. They decided to slander me and get the press to target me claiming I was trying to manipulate the market. It was an interesting strategy, but one I cared nothing about since I was primarily institutional and corporate advisor, and they were not really interested in silver.

The journalist from the Wall Street Journal called me. He accused me of this nonsense and we argued. It got quite heated. He said if silver was being manipulated, then give him the name. I told him he wouldn’t believe me anyway. He demanded the name and so I said fine, go ahead, let me see you print it, knowing he never would. The name I gave him was Warren Buffett. He laughed. Told me everyone knew Buffett did not trade commodities I told him that was how much he knew.

The Wall Street Journal published the article. The London newspapers were fed stories by the “Club” that I was now the largest silver trader in the world. This became all a joke to me. Even the CFTC could look at positions and knew I was not a big player in silver.

The mistake made by the “Club” by turning out the press against me, was they actually created such a worldwide story that the CFTC was forced to call me. They knew I was not the source. They asked me, where was the manipulation taking place? I told them it was in London, out of their jurisdiction. They told me that they could pick up the phone and find out. I told them that they had to make that clear decision. I hung up. Never did I expect that they would really do anything.

A few hours later, my phone rang. It was a good source in London who also was helping to monitor the “Club” actions. He told me that the Bank of England had called an immediate meeting of all silver brokers in London in the morning. I was shocked. The CFTC had made the call. But then again, I had given them no names so perhaps in their mind, this was fair game.

Within the hour, Warren Buffett made a press announcement. He admitted he had purchased $1 billion worth of silver, in London . He denied he was manipulating the market. Claimed the silver was a long – term investment. Everyone was shocked that Buffett was suddenly exposed as a commodity trader after all the next day, the wall Street Journal called me. The writer asked – “How did you know?” I told him it was my job to know! Silver thereafter declined and made new lows going into 1999. So much for the long-term investment.

There have been major manipulations of markets such as rhodium and then there was the manipulation of Platinum. Cornering a supply is far too risky. What the “club” did was to join forces with Russian politicians. The deal struck was to recall the Russian supply of platinum to suddenly take an inventory. Platinum soared in price. Of course the long positions were already laid in before the announcement. Russia had never before recalled its entire supply to take an inventory. Nevertheless, it worked. They were able to force platinum up for the auto – industry were buyers. At the top, the “club” sold their long positions, reversed into short positions, and then instructed the Russians to end the inventory. Platinum crashed. Even Ford Motor Company sued over that one.


Here is the New York Times from February 5th, 1998. Note that the CFTC had no comment because it was Buffett. The Wall Street Journal had called me and I was warning our clients in September 1997 “they” were going to take silver up to $7 by January. On September 30th 1997 the stories played headlines –

“Silver Prices Hit Six-Month High On Steadily Declining Reserves, By  PALLAVI GOGOI AP-Dow Jones News Service Updated Sept. 30, 1997 12:01 a.m. ET NEW YORK — Silver futures surged to a six-month high at the Comex division of the New York Mercantile Exchange, a move analysts said was triggered by steadily declining warehouse stocks. The rally was boosted by preplaced purchase orders around the $5-per-ounce level…”

This was the news created for the manipulation the feed to the press that was constantly played out in the newspapers. The Wall Street Journal again reported on November 17, 1997:

“Silver Futures Prices Leap On Hints of Tight Supplies”,

and again on December 4, 1997 the Wall Street Journal from London reported:

“Silver Surges on Strength In Supply-Demand Status By NEIL BEHRMANN Special to The Wall Street Journal Updated Dec. 5, 1997 12:01 a.m. ET LONDON — Gold may be in the doghouse, but silver is soaring like a bird”.

The reporting of shortages continued to fuel the rally. The Wall Street Journal reported again December 24, 1997 with information feed to them by the manipulators:

“Silver Futures Advance As Inventories Plunge”

I have always wrote about how the “club” coordinated to move a market for a quick gain. That was it. Then they move to the next market. They did not stay and perpetually maintain the same trade.

huntbrothers

So do not confuse coordinated trading with systemic manipulation claiming that is why the metals have not rallied. That is just not true. Look at the dollar and the entire surrounding markets. Take the blinders off for once. Just as the “club” put out news in the press to get people to buy the silver, they did the same going into 1980 telling the world it was the Hunts. They sucked in everyone at the top, changed the rules at the exchange who is in their pocket (corruption) and made it less to short than go long. They then told the CFTC to charge the Hunts for the whole scam.

Why did the CFTC not even question Buffett? The CFTC does what the bankers tell them to do all the time. They would never charge Buffett of Phibro for buying the silver in London to make it appear that the supply collapsed when all they did was move it from NYC to London. It was not used. Buffett then turned around and sold it all – so much for the long-term investment. Members of the “club” can do anything because they hire the lawyers from the CFTC and SEC known as the Revolving Door which is the real problem sustaining corruption. When you have mainstream media, courts, and the regulators all on a short leash held by the club, the club has been able to do as they please for decades.

You want to pretend I am wrong so you can feel better about being wrong? Have a nice day. And by the way, good luck with the losses. Technical Analysis will tell you when markets are being played. If you want to make a difference, stop the “manipulation” nonsense and deal with the real issue – the club owns the them all, media, courts, and regulators.